Latest topics | » THE DISTINGUISHED CONDUCT MEDAL![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Thu Sep 05, 2024 11:16 pm by Julian Whybra » 61451 John Evans. Able Seaman.![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Wed Sep 04, 2024 5:15 pm by Matthew Turl » 9312 Sapper H Cuthbert 5th Field Coy RE![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Wed Sep 04, 2024 11:53 am by Julian Whybra » Who’s who in this photo?![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Tue Sep 03, 2024 12:44 pm by ianwood » Sir Robert William Jackson ![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Mon Sep 02, 2024 10:24 am by Julian Whybra » Memorial to Wolseley![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Sep 01, 2024 8:47 pm by John Young » Lieutenant & Adjutant Spencer Frederick Chichester, 2nd 21st![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Sep 01, 2024 7:52 pm by Rory Reynolds » Last of the 24th at Isandhlwana![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Sep 01, 2024 7:51 am by Julian Whybra » On this day 28th August, 1879![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Sep 01, 2024 7:28 am by Julian Whybra » Alfred Ducat - N.N.C. Help with plotting his career![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Thu Aug 29, 2024 6:58 pm by Rory Reynolds » Corporal James Frowen Williams F Company. ![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Thu Aug 29, 2024 8:46 am by Julian Whybra » Army Pay Department Personnel![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Aug 25, 2024 11:51 pm by Julian Whybra » Baron Von Steitencron![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Aug 25, 2024 10:32 am by Julian Whybra » Troop Despatch ![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sat Aug 24, 2024 10:15 pm by Eddie » Private 35/1430 James Priddle 1/13th Regiment![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sat Aug 24, 2024 8:09 am by Roobie257 » Zulu powder horn![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Fri Aug 23, 2024 5:22 pm by Rob D » Telescope v. field glasses![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Fri Aug 23, 2024 7:07 am by Julian Whybra » A Hungarian soldier in the Zulu War (?)![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Wed Aug 21, 2024 5:14 am by 90th » 90th foot sgt T. Collins 214![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Tue Aug 20, 2024 3:04 pm by johnman » Zulu "Corps"![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Tue Aug 20, 2024 11:43 am by Hobbes » amaKwenke amabutho![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Tue Aug 20, 2024 11:23 am by Hobbes » A story regarding Younghusband's charge. Hearsay or a possibility? ![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Aug 18, 2024 5:48 pm by Danny1960 » Hill of the Sphinx for sale open to offers![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sat Aug 17, 2024 6:44 pm by ciroferrara » Information help please ![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Fri Aug 16, 2024 4:44 pm by Roobie257 » Capt. Geo. Shepstone![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Tue Aug 13, 2024 4:14 pm by Julian Whybra » Thomas William george 58th regiment 1880’s SA![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Tue Aug 13, 2024 12:05 pm by Alstar » Private John Scott 24th Regiment a fugitive at large![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Aug 11, 2024 7:50 pm by Julian Whybra » Sergt. Woods N.N.C.![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Fri Aug 09, 2024 4:41 pm by Julian Whybra » Who led the Naval Brigade at Gingindlovu ?![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Thu Aug 08, 2024 9:32 pm by Herbert West » Herbert's Zulu war models![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Thu Aug 08, 2024 7:06 pm by Herbert West » Studies in the Zulu War volumes![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Wed Aug 07, 2024 2:31 pm by Julian Whybra » 80th Foot Information Request![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Tue Aug 06, 2024 6:28 pm by Bill8183 » Henderson and the NNH at Rorke's Drift ![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Mon Aug 05, 2024 7:53 pm by SRB1965 » Hamilton Browne's birthday![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Mon Aug 05, 2024 2:41 pm by Julian Whybra » 4,000 registered members.![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Aug 04, 2024 6:21 pm by Julian Whybra |
September 2024 | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun |
---|
| | | | | | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | | | | | | | Calendar |
|
Top posting users this month | |
New topics | » Memorial to Wolseley![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sun Sep 01, 2024 8:47 pm by John Young » On this day 28th August, 1879![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Wed Aug 28, 2024 10:37 am by John Young » Alfred Ducat - N.N.C. Help with plotting his career![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Mon Aug 26, 2024 1:34 pm by Rory Reynolds » Zulu powder horn![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Fri Aug 23, 2024 5:22 pm by Rob D » Troop Despatch ![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Thu Aug 22, 2024 12:18 am by Eddie » Who’s who in this photo?![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Tue Aug 20, 2024 3:53 am by Danny1960 » Hill of the Sphinx for sale open to offers![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Sat Aug 17, 2024 6:44 pm by ciroferrara » Information help please ![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Thu Aug 15, 2024 7:40 pm by Roobie257 » amaKwenke amabutho![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/fa/empty.gif) Thu Aug 15, 2024 6:54 pm by Julian Whybra |
Zero tolerance to harassment and bullying. |
Due to recent events on this forum, we have now imposed a zero tolerance to harassment and bullying. All reports will be treated seriously, and will lead to a permanent ban of both membership and IP address.
Any member blatantly corresponding in a deliberate and provoking manner will be removed from the forum as quickly as possible after the event.
If any members are being harassed behind the scenes PM facility by any member/s here at 1879zuluwar.com please do not hesitate to forward the offending text.
We are all here to communicate and enjoy the various discussions and information on the Anglo Zulu War of 1879. Opinions will vary, you will agree and disagree with one another, we will have debates, and so it goes.
There is no excuse for harassment or bullying of anyone by another person on this site.
The above applies to the main frame areas of the forum.
The ring which is the last section on the forum, is available to those members who wish to partake in slagging matches. That section cannot be viewed by guests and only viewed by members that wish to do so. |
Fair Use Notice | Fair use notice.
This website may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not been specifically authorised by the copyright owner.
We are making such material and images are available in our efforts to advance the understanding of the “Anglo Zulu War of 1879. For educational & recreational purposes.
We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material, as provided for in UK copyright law. The information is purely for educational and research purposes only. No profit is made from any part of this website.
If you hold the copyright on any material on the site, or material refers to you, and you would like it to be removed, please let us know and we will work with you to reach a resolution. |
| | Was Charlie Harford a liar? | |
|
+5Chard1879 24th Frank Allewell Kenny 6pdr 9 posters | Author | Message |
---|
6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Sun Sep 28, 2014 5:13 pm | |
| While reading DEAD WAS EVERYTHING (Smith) last night I came across an essay about the recovery of the 1st Battalion colours that Melvill famously carried from the battlefield until he was killed on the banks of the Buffalo. The gist of it was that there are various accounts of how Melvill & Coghill bodies' were recovered. Most of us have read Harford's account which casts him as the central actor in the drama; especially during the return the next day when the stanchion or staff for the colours was found wedged between some rocks in the river.
Smith reviews other accounts however which include far more participants in the search on both successive days. In those Harford is hardly the central agent; he does not discover the flag staff at all.
I don't really care about the details of the recovery but, if the other accounts are accurate, doesn't it throw an entirely different light on Harford's diary? He is one of my favorite characters in this drama and I scarcely think I'm alone in feeling that way about him. That has made me weigh his testimony more heavily than others. Do we have to read his diary the way we read Maori's accounts--i.e. with heightened skepticism? (Browne is one of those that seems to contradict Harford's account btw.)
Think about it. This was supposedly a DIARY he was keeping, not something intended for publication. So, was he lying even to himself...or was it not really ever a diary? Or were the other accounts put up jobs? |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Sun Sep 28, 2014 5:59 pm | |
| |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Kenny
Posts : 598 Join date : 2013-05-07 Location : Brecon
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 12:20 am | |
| The answer is probably yes - to give the impression that he played a key role, whereas he was most likely just an onlooker to events. His account varies with the official account written by Wilsone Black who commanded the recce party. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 7:22 am | |
| Kenny,
If you are in Brecon perhaps you have access to this. Smith says there is an entry in a digest kept by the 1/24th saying:
"Hillier found the Cover, Trow the Crest, and finally about 50 yards above Harber raised the Colour from the water, it having been jammed between the stones."
Hillier, Trow and Harber were NNC officers. Harford is mentioned as one of the other 16 officers along for the ride though. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 1:29 pm | |
| Surly someone (else) can put up Blacks account!! But to call a man a liar!. a brave man at that, and remember his diary was personal never intended for publication, and if he did embellish his own involvement..what of it..i hear and see enough bs in my brief time on here..to lead off calling a truly fascinating man a liar, and then not have the way to facilitate the claim further!, but expecting others to do the work.. thats bs. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Frank Allewell
![Frank Allewell](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/32-19.jpg)
Posts : 8572 Join date : 2009-09-21 Age : 77 Location : Cape Town South Africa
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 2:20 pm | |
| David Rattray is turning in his grave right now. Interesting thing about the comment 6lb posted is that harber lifted up the pole and the crest dropped out and was lost. Where does Trow fit in? Cheers |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 4:05 pm | |
| Springbok -- that was my first thought upon reading this...because it ruins such a pleasing narrative. My second thought was "and how is Mike Snook going to square this with his claims that Victorian officers (in British regiments anyway) always bore themselves as paragons of virtue and therefore we should never think in terms of things like "cover ups" or, God forbid, cowardice. (Not that our bug collector engaged in either of those two latter activities, just that he turns out to be not only fallible, but intentionally so!)
Xhosa - my experience is that when somebody records something they know not to be true in a diary, journal, day book etc...that they are indeed intending for it to be published...but I can't prove that here. We do know for a fact that (if we accept the accuracy of Black's report) Harford embellished his role in these events and did so even beyond what Maori dared squeeze in about himself.
The story is also interesting for how the accounts changed over time and the accuracy of Norris-Newman's journalism...for better or worse.
|
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 4:36 pm | |
| Also, I don't mean to ignore requests for more information but I am quoting the relevant sentence in the entry of the 1/24th digest which, according to Smith, is a summary based on Black's report. Smith does not quote directly from Black's report. Is a copy of that extant? I don't know.
In this article Smith first quotes Wolseley on desirability of officers dying on the battlefield with their men rather than saving colours. He then quotes Glynn's report, Harford's journal (Child), Noggs, Times of Natal, Natal Mercury and finally Hamilton-Browne.
|
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 24th
![24th](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/20-37.jpg)
Posts : 1862 Join date : 2009-03-25
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 8:36 pm | |
| [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]Source:THE ZULU WAR. Bay of Plenty Times, Volume VIII, Issue 720, 24 April 1879, Page 3 |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 24th
![24th](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/20-37.jpg)
Posts : 1862 Join date : 2009-03-25
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 9:03 pm | |
| |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 9:46 pm | |
| Wow, those are both very interesting. The first because it's a third newspaper account that differs with the two prior. And the second posting because it is different in telling details. Some accounts say the Colour was found the same day as the bodies and the others on a subsequent one. The Natal Witness says days later and repeats Harford's assertion that he spotted the pole even if he didn't retrieve it himself. (Harber did.) So, in effect, the NW represents Harford's version (which Browne also seems to echo.) Noggs makes it clear that Black's "yarning" was his source. Smith believes both the newspaper accounts he quotes (Times of Natal and Natal Mercury) were also derivative of Norris-Newman. In those the bodies and Colour are discovered within moments on the same day. In other words there is only one expedition mentioned. Smith points out that Harford frames the finding of the bodies during the first expedition as virtually a two man affair: him and Black. Black features Commandant Cooper, not Harford, in his telling. In the end it seems that Black's version of the search(es) is the one that entered the official record (via Glyn?) albeit on the day (Feb. 4) after the bodies were discovered. That said, far more of us read Charlie Harford's account. Thanks 24th! ![Salute](/users/1313/16/75/50/smiles/770175799.gif) |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Chard1879
![Chard1879](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/107-47.jpg)
Posts : 1261 Join date : 2010-04-12
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 10:29 pm | |
| |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 10:54 pm | |
| - Quote :
- Lay off Harford, a fine man!.
I think you're missing the point. You've posted Harford's version printed many decades after the event. That doesn't impact the argument one way or the other. There is no question but that has become the commonly printed version of the event. We all know as much. The question here is what really happened and can it be proved one way or the other. And btw, a man can lie and be brave. They are not mutually exclusive. Smith seems to think at a minimum Harford embellished his role in the undertakings. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Mon Sep 29, 2014 11:19 pm | |
| Version?!!!. its Regimental history! missing the point! you have not made one that makes any sense..waffle away to your hearts content, i have said it before, i have you exact! no substance, very little knowledge, please do the necessary legwork and take in what i post.. i don't wish to offend you, but i expect you will take offence anyway. ![Very Happy](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_biggrin.png) |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 12:19 am | |
| Footnote 1 Verbatim: "This account is largely based on one contributed to the Natal Mercury by Lt., then Colonel, Harford in 1923." |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 1:28 am | |
| What about the direct quote from Black, give it up. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 2:55 am | |
| - xhosa2000 wrote:
- What about the direct quote from Black, give it up.
You're really not getting it, are you? You're arguing with a piece written by Keith Smith called THE QUEEN'S COLOUR on pages 114-119 of his recently reprinted work, DEAD WAS EVERYTHING. You're not arguing with me. Harford is my favorite character in the whole drama. "The extracts which next are the words of Captain (local rank) Harford, staff officer to Colonel Durnford of the 1st Regiment NNC, who places himself at the center of the action he describes, while at the same time contradicting Colonel Glyn's own account of events." (p.115) Glyn says he sent Black. Neither Glyn nor Black makes mention of Harford. " It is most unlikely that Harford's description of the first expedition, seemingly consisting of only himself and Black, and which could be thought ambigous, is correct. " (p.118) "There is yet one more account to be considered, although it's inclusion here is solely for the purpose of exposing the was Victorian gentlemen were quite beyond shame when it came to insinuating themselves into a good story." (p.117) This is referring to Maori who does just that. Browne claims he was going along to find the bodies but was called away by Glyn at the last minute. And why is Smith drawing our attention to Maori being Maori? Because of unsubstantiated quotes of the type favored by Browne that exist in Harford's account: "Harford, it is nothing but your right to carry this Colour to its destination." Really? If that doesn't sound like a line Browne might have concocted, I don't know what would be. In any case what you didn't manage to quite cut off is that BLACK was the one who presented the Colour after all, NOT Harford for which a suitable excuse is found. Again, conveniently inconclusive, but shades of Maori at his best... To cap it off the 1/24th Battalion ledger states: "The party returned to Rorke's Drift and gave over the Colour to Col. Glyn which was next day escorted by the above party [of 19 officers, not two] to Helpmakaar and restored to the two Companies now representing the 1/24 Regiment.[136]" Again, no mention of Harford as a pivotal figure...in fact no mention is made of him at all. To me it seems quite possible the quotes attributed by Harford to Black are literary license, (which is to say made up from whole cloth.) In any case there is no independent corroboration for them. Smith then ends with a terrific quote from the journalist William Russell on how the 3rd Buffs and 99th Regiment treated their Colours. It's a very interesting perspective. ![You need to study mo](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_study.png)
Last edited by 6pdr on Tue Sep 30, 2014 3:08 am; edited 1 time in total |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 3:04 am | |
| You have lost, if you ever had the plot. ![Very Happy](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_biggrin.png) goodnite. More from me when I have slept a. While. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 10:27 am | |
| Calm yourself Mr 6pdr.. you cite Mr Smith like he has some god like status.. he is an author ( and a bloody good one two! ) but assertions and then opinion do not make facts. if you remember the part of your initial post inferred that Charles Harford was a liar..you seem to have dropped that, so have settled instead that he had exaggerated his role in finding the Queens Colour..my own first response was to say well ' what of it ' do we all not exaggerate at times? here is the Smith piece from the 1st edition in its entirety. i dont know if i will be getting the second till i know if anything useful is added, i have people who can be relied apon to let me know on that score. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 10:46 am | |
| Of course you are aware that the regimental Record's of the 24th Regiment were destroyed at Isandhlwana! and that a reconstituted version was compiled! in them there is no individual naming of The Colonials, they were air- brushed so to speak..Mr Atkinson corrected that omission when the Regimental history was revisited at the invitation of the Regiment!. Now i say again, which is basically all that i am saying Charles Harford was not a 'LIAR' so retract that please.. i have one more snippet to scan and present then i will consider my say...said!. ![Very Happy](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_biggrin.png) |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | ADMIN
![ADMIN](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/1-44.jpg)
Posts : 4358 Join date : 2008-11-01 Age : 65 Location : KENT
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 11:12 am | |
| Xhosa your replies to 6pdr posts, sound somewhat antagonising, when he is simply putting forward what I would call reasonable discussion. By all means debate you case, but try and do it in a Gentlemanly manner. If the topic is upsetting to you, perhaps it would be best not to contribute on this occasion. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 11:33 am | |
| I understand what you say, this topic is in no way upsetting to me, i have debated my case, vigorously, without aggression. you are out of order and to quick to jump in.. your comment and try and do it in a gentlemanly manner, i find extremely offensive! in what sense am i expected to behave like a gentleman? and please tell me what that even is? the person in question left me a pm. baiting me! i replied to him in a manner suited in my opinion. if you are saying that he is for example..a minor and in which case allowances would certainly apply! but i have no idea so treated him as an adult, capable of looking after him self.
Gentleman! no mate, i have never claimed that.. i did not know it was a requirement! |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | ADMIN
![ADMIN](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/1-44.jpg)
Posts : 4358 Join date : 2008-11-01 Age : 65 Location : KENT
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 11:50 am | |
| Xhosa. Control your passions. A professional must keep cool and thoughtful in times of stress. It’s not all about you two; there are other members on here that would like to participate, but don’t because they don’t want to get embroiled in a childish arguments. Use the PM Facility or the ring section to debate your case, vigorously.
|
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Guest Guest
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 12:10 pm | |
| Yes admin, but again you mistake me for some other! i am not a professional. i dont know what you mean when you say that! please dont ask me to control my passions.. again i dont know why you would choose such a phrase.. i am icy cool at all times..i always type as i'm thinking, but always check before i hit the send button..i am truly appalled at the notion that i have been preventing others from posting or presenting their opinions.. i encourage at all times vigorous debate, yes, i am a plain speaking man. but dont believe i am deliberately aggressive or offensive!. i want this to be the best forum of its type in the world, and fear that if it becomes to bland and colourless it will go the way others have gone before!
With over 1700 members i have often thought..' where are they ' i am not a person who would go out of the way to be condescending to any poster who asked even the most basic question! you as admin have to be fair, even handed and above all impartial. i have no beef with you on that score.. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | ADMIN
![ADMIN](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/1-44.jpg)
Posts : 4358 Join date : 2008-11-01 Age : 65 Location : KENT
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 12:23 pm | |
| - Xhosa wrote:
- i dont know what you mean when you
say that! please dont ask me to control my passions.. again i dont know why you would choose such a phrase How disappointing. I thought you, would have got that. Zulu Dawn CREALOCK "Mr. Harford... control your passions. A professional soldier must keep cool and thoughtful in times of stress." |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | garywilson1
![garywilson1](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/9-1.jpg)
Posts : 374 Join date : 2009-01-22 Age : 62 Location : Timisoara , Romania
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 1:49 pm | |
| One man's lie is another man's exaggeration ? The OED definition of a liar is simply;
"A person who tells lies:".
|
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 2:28 pm | |
| Thank you for injecting that note of sanity Mr. Wilson, but I don't think we should descend any further into a rabbit hole of semantics.
I doubt Smith's goal was to "besmirch the reputation of such a fine upstanding citizen" or any such Victorian hornswoggle; nor is it mine. Harford will continue to stand out for his eccentricities in any case.
The question I was asking is whether we have to review Harford's considerable contributions to the history of this period with a more critical eye. Is it possible he gilded the Lilly a bit when recounting his adventures at Sirhayo's holdout, or chasing after Matshana? And if all of the "daring do" didn't really happen does that change the historical record substantively? I don't know, but I feel as if, in the past, I have had too positive a bias towards him.
I am suggesting that I ought to read his journal in exactly the same way that I read Marori Browne's books -- dispassionately. Isn't that merely the standard that truly professional historians must hold themselves to in any case?
Last edited by 6pdr on Tue Sep 30, 2014 2:35 pm; edited 1 time in total |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Frank Allewell
![Frank Allewell](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/32-19.jpg)
Posts : 8572 Join date : 2009-09-21 Age : 77 Location : Cape Town South Africa
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 2:34 pm | |
| I think Keith is barking up the wrong tree. And I say that with the greatest respect for the man. In all the accounts there are discepancies. I don't recall Rev Smith being included in any of the parties? And the mention of Trow finding the Crest is patently incorrect, the crest fell out as the standard was raised out of the water by Harber. The initial account from Harford rings true and is only discounted by KS because it sounds unlikely that they would be riding around in a 'dangerous setting'. That's really wrong, they were riding in an area regularly patrolled, Harford himself had just come of a patrol, and in Natal not Zulu land. There had been no signs of enemy activity over the Buffalo so I would disagree that the area was dangerous. In addition men were riding back and forth to Helpmakaar, there are a number of references to visitors to RD and the track to Helpmakaar is on the road between RD and Elands Kraal, not to far from the grave site of M and C. I would believe its highly possible that the two of them rode of on the 3rd to explore. The fact that Harford is not high lighted as being present on the following day is not that surprising, he was a junior officer and Black has singled out the senior officers for mention. The two separate summaries, by Black and Glyn really have no significant differences. Glyn says that when he herd where the M and C had come to grief he sent out Black to have a look. Harford says Black approached Glyn, possibly telling him where the bodies could be found, and Glyn agreed to the patrol. Theres no difference in the two tales. Glyn doesn't mention Harford and Black has no reason to. Its always possible that embelishments are made to stories but not when they can be repudiated by other living sources surely? Harford finding the cover is just such a situation, he was with Harbor at the time and recal a conversation with him. If that didn't take place Im pretty confident that Harbor or one of the other party would have contradicted. Norris Newmans account says quite blatantly wrongly that the colors were found by Black. Definitly a hearsay report, in similar fashion the other news paper reports. And of course the old ruffian himself, Browne, who can say that he hadn't discussed things with Harford, possibly this was the catalyst for Harford to talk to Black and instigate the search.
No sorry Keith I would beg to differ, Harford has been much maligned and I don't believe that for one second.
Cheers |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Frank Allewell
![Frank Allewell](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/32-19.jpg)
Posts : 8572 Join date : 2009-09-21 Age : 77 Location : Cape Town South Africa
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 2:40 pm | |
| As an aside, my key board is acting up and what seems to be really bad spelling is a result of that. That's my bloody excuse and Im sticking to it. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 3:08 pm | |
| Springbok,
I take your points but I think there are (at a minimum) two distinctly different versions of events -- one that originates with Black and another Harford. I can speculate there was a feeling of competition between them but that is merely speculation and trivial in any case.
That said, the place where the two fell is sufficiently close to Sihayo's former hold out that it might still be considered a dangerous area in the wake of a disaster like Isandlwana. I do agree that Black and Glyn present substantially the same summary. It effaces Harford's role and maybe that was the root of his retelling. You say Norris Newman is a "hearsay account" but he claims he got it direct from Black. Harford OTOH claims Black was the one to request official permission but he really took Black along. And as you rightly point out, a discussion with Maori may even have been the catalyst for Harford instigating the search (through Black.)
And that's what's got me suspicious. The entire account smells to high heaven of Maori IMO. We all like Harford so much because he's typically somewhat understated. In no other case do I remember reading him as a braggart. In this case he's atypically egotistical however.
Perhaps it's all in my imagination...but I do not believe so. I see the hand of Maori in this account! |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Frank Allewell
![Frank Allewell](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/32-19.jpg)
Posts : 8572 Join date : 2009-09-21 Age : 77 Location : Cape Town South Africa
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 4:43 pm | |
| Hi 6pd Yep Newmans account is definitely second hand, and very inaccurate, and do the other accounts efface Harford, or merely reflect the times in that junior officers are there to do guard duties and menial tasks. I would think that's really the scenario in that the senior officers claimed as their right all the glory. Typically Victorian military attitude? I stick up for Harford because of his record, its pretty damned good and he doesn't make a lot of it himself, in fact a lot of his exploits would be unheard of if it wasn't for his contemporaries. Right now the ghost of David Rattray is preparing to haunt an expat pom in Aussie. ![Very Happy](https://2img.net/i/fa/i/smiles/icon_biggrin.png) So be careful Im pretty sure he knows how to get to the older colonies |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Kenny
Posts : 598 Join date : 2013-05-07 Location : Brecon
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 5:37 pm | |
| Next time I am able I will post the account in Records of 1/24th written by Black as he uses the word 'glen' - being a Glaswegian - when referring to the river and fugitives' drift - which Keith Smith consulted for his book. Black mentions all the names involved, nevertheless according to Black Harford does seemed to have played a minor role in this episode.
As Harford was a particular favourite of DR - around which he based his stories - like the characters in movie 'Zulu' we remember with affection these stories when perhaps they were an embellishment of the true facts. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 6:29 pm | |
| |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Chard1879
![Chard1879](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/107-47.jpg)
Posts : 1261 Join date : 2010-04-12
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 7:23 pm | |
| Most soldiers bend the truth somewhat. Why should this man be any different? Perhaps that why it was never meant for publication. . |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Dave
![Dave](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/1-55.gif)
Posts : 1603 Join date : 2009-09-21
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Tue Sep 30, 2014 10:16 pm | |
| - 24th wrote:
- [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Source:THE ZULU WAR. Bay of Plenty Times, Volume VIII, Issue 720, 24 April 1879, Page 3
I notice in this article, Harford is mentioned, albeit the name being wrongly spelled. But the credit is given to Harbour, based on the date of the article possibly more the truth. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Wed Oct 01, 2014 12:28 am | |
| - Dave wrote:
- I notice in this article, Harford is mentioned, albeit the name being wrongly spelled. But the credit is given to Harbour, based on the date of the article possibly more the truth.
Just confirming Harber/Harbour and Harford are different officers. The 1/24th journal lists both among the participants of the second day search party. It occurred to me that Harbour/Harber might be a misspelling of Harford when I first saw it, but no. (And I suppose I should also add that in Harford's own account (posted on the first page of this thread by Xhosa) he says he pointed Captain Harber to the pole that Captain Harber pulled from the river. So Harbour is not a mispelling of Harford it is a mispelling of Harber.) |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | impi
![impi](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/153-96.jpg)
Posts : 2308 Join date : 2010-07-02 Age : 44
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Wed Oct 01, 2014 8:30 am | |
| Here's the same story with the correct spellings. Scroll to recovering the colours. [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | Kenny
Posts : 598 Join date : 2013-05-07 Location : Brecon
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Wed Oct 15, 2014 8:00 pm | |
| As promised the Records of the 1/2th Regiment state:
On 4th February Lieut Colonel Black who in a previous reconnaissance had discovered the bodies of Lieuts Melvill & Coghill set out with the following officers of the NNC – Captains Harber, Gubbins, Greaves, Underhill, MacIntosh, Lieuts Trow, Hillier, Harford, Murray, Sheppard, Barry, Higginson, Godfrey, Goldsburg, Pohl, Sutherland, Long, Ryder and Raw, to try and find the lost Queens Colour of the 1/24th Regiment. The party raised a cairn over the bodies of Mevill & Coghill, and descended into the glen through which the Buffalo runs in deep curves about 400 yards lower downstream than where Melvill crossed first, Hillier found the Cover, Trow the Crest, and finally about 50 yards above Harber raised the Colour from the water, it having jammed between the stones. The party returned to Rorke’s Drift and gave over the Colour to Colonel Glyn which was next day escorted by the above party to the two Companies now representing the 1/24th Regiment.
On 14th April, the bodies of Lieutenants Coghill & Melvill which were covered by a cairn by the party under Colonel Black on the 4th February, were buried close to the spot where they fell, & on the rock above a Marble Cross, the gift of Sir Bartle Frere was set up.
|
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | 6pdr
![6pdr](https://2img.net/u/1313/16/75/50/avatars/908-11.jpg)
Posts : 1086 Join date : 2012-05-12 Location : NYC
![Was Charlie Harford a liar? Empty](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | Subject: Re: Was Charlie Harford a liar? Wed Oct 15, 2014 8:27 pm | |
| - Kenny wrote:
- As promised the Records of the 1/2th Regiment state:
Thanks for closing the loop. |
| ![Go down](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) | | | Was Charlie Harford a liar? | |
|
Similar topics | ![+](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif) |
|
| Permissions in this forum: | You cannot reply to topics in this forum
| |
| |
| |